Whisky Review/Tasting: Caol Ila 12 years

Physical Whisky Characteristics

Origin: Caol Ila Distillery, Islay, Scotland.
Type: Single Malt Scotch Whisky.
Distillation and Maturation Process: Aged for 12 years, the whisky is noted for its peaty and smoky character, which is a hallmark of Islay whiskies. The maturation process allows for the smoky aromas to oxidize into more stable substances, reducing the intensity of the smoke over time.
Age Statement: 12 years.
ABV: 43%.
Color and Clarity: Not explicitly described, but the whisky's oiliness suggests a rich texture.
Bottle Design: Standard size bottles are mentioned, along with a collection of smaller bottles (20 centiliters) for tasting. The design includes a small cork, which the host appreciates.

Balance of Flavors: Described as having a very good balance between bonfire smoke, medicinal smoke, and the citrus note characteristic of the distillery. The whisky is likened to a well-balanced table with three legs of equal length.
Unique Characteristics: Notable for its oily texture, which provides warmth and covers the mouth, reducing the impact of alcohol and smoke. The smoke is described as not too strong, with a blend of bonfire and medicinal phenols. Citrus notes, particularly lime, are present, adding freshness.
Comparison: While not directly compared to other whiskies, the flavor profile is distinct from typical Highland malts, which are sweeter and maltier.

Distillery Background: Caol Ila became famous post-2000, transitioning from primarily producing for the blended whisky industry to marketing its own range of single malt whiskies.
Production Insights: The distillery is a significant supplier of peaty malt whisky for blends like Johnny Walker and J&B, using its strong peaty character as a "spice" in these blends.

Islay Whiskies: Caol Ila embodies the characteristic smoky and peaty profile of Islay whiskies, contributing to the island's reputation for such distinctive spirits.

Horst Luening's Opinion: "It has the real balance, a very very good balance... The whiskey is close to perfect."
Tasting Notes: Descriptions of the whisky's flavor profile emphasize its complexity and balance, distinguishing it from sweeter, maltier Highland malts.

Caol Ila 12 years is a single malt Scotch whisky from Islay, known for its peaty and smoky character.
The whisky has a balanced flavor profile, with bonfire and medicinal smoke, citrus notes, and an oily texture.
It is part of Caol Ila's range of single malts, a shift from its historical role as a supplier for blended whiskies.
The distillery's contribution to blends like Johnny Walker and J&B highlights its significant peaty character.
Horst Luening praises the whisky for its balance and quality, describing it as close to perfect.

Peat Lovers: Individuals who appreciate the smoky and peaty profile of Islay whiskies will likely enjoy Caol Ila 12 years.
Experienced Whisky Drinkers: Those with a palate for complex, balanced flavors and an interest in the subtleties of maturation effects on smoke intensity.
Newcomers with a Taste for Adventure: Beginners curious about the diverse profiles of Scotch whisky, especially the distinctive characteristics of Islay malts, might find Caol Ila 12 an intriguing choice, provided they are open to its strong peaty and smoky flavors.